Directory Backlinks: What 14 of Our Listings Actually Gave Us
We reopened 14 Repute Post directory and review-site profiles on 20 November 2026 and logged what each one gave us: live or not, indexable or not, the rel on the link, and the cost.
Hamza Haroon
Updated · 15 min read
On 3 November 2026 we opened every Repute Post profile on review sites and business directories. The same business appeared under four names (Repute Post, ReputePost, Reputepost and Repute Post Inc) and in three different locations. Only one of them is right: Cardiff, in the United Kingdom.
Fixing that took most of a week, and it raised the question this post answers: what do directory backlinks actually give a business in 2026? So on 20 November we reopened the 14 public profiles in this log and recorded what each one does. Is the page live? Can Google index it? Does it link to reputepost.com, and with which rel value? And what does a listing there cost?
The short version: 14 profiles, 11 live, 3 followed links (one of them through a redirect), 8 nofollow links and 3 profiles with no link at all. If you came here for a backlink directory or a list of directories for SEO, this list is short on purpose. The sections after it explain which kinds of directory are worth your time, and which to skip.
How we checked each listing
A directory backlink is a link to your site from your profile on a directory: a business listing, a software review site, a startup database or a launch platform. Whether it helps depends on four things you can check yourself. We checked all four for each profile on 20 November 2026:
- Is the page live? We looked at the HTTP status of the profile URL. A 404 or 410 means nobody can see the listing, and neither can a search engine.
- Can it be indexed? We read the robots meta tag and the X-Robots-Tag header. A noindex profile can still send visitors, but Google won't show it in results.
- Does it link to us, and how? We read every link pointing at reputepost.com, directly or through the directory's own redirect URL, and its rel. No rel at all means the link is followed; otherwise the rel says nofollow, ugc or sponsored.
- What does a listing cost? We took this from the directory's own pricing or help page, or from the options it showed us when we submitted.
Each page was read twice: once as the server sends it (Python requests), and once after its scripts had run (headless Chromium), because some directories add links with JavaScript. We did not record emails or phone numbers from any profile.
To run the same check on one of your own listings, open the profile in Chrome, press F12, paste this into the Console tab and put your own domain in place of yourdomain.com:
console.table([...document.querySelectorAll('a[href*="yourdomain.com"]')]
.map(a => ({ rel: a.rel || 'none (followed)', href: a.href })));
Some directories send their "Visit website" button through a redirect on their own domain (EliteAI Tools and SoftwareSuggest do), so the snippet won't list it. For those, right-click the button, choose Inspect and read the rel on that one link. To check for noindex, open View Source and search the page for "noindex".
Our backlink directory log: 14 profiles checked on 20 November 2026
The table covers every Repute Post profile we opened and read in full on 20 November: software directories, review sites, a company database, a startup community and two launch platforms. "Followed" means the link to reputepost.com has no nofollow, ugc or sponsored value. Costs are for a basic listing, as each directory publishes them.
| Profile | Type | Status | Indexable | Link to reputepost.com | Name and location shown | Cost to list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SaaSHub | Software directory | Live | Yes | Followed (main link, no rel; 2 other links nofollow) | Repute Post (no location) | Free; a featured listing is paid |
| ProvenExpert | Review site | Live | Yes | Followed (company name link, no rel) | Repute Post, Cardiff, United Kingdom | Free basic account |
| EliteAI Tools | AI tool directory | Live | Yes | Followed, through a 302 on its own /go URL | Repute Post (no location) | Nothing: the site made the page |
| GoodFirms | Software directory | Live | Yes | nofollow (all 5 links) | Repute Post, United Kingdom (HQ) | Free; sponsorship is paid |
| SoftwareSuggest | Software directory | Live | Yes | nofollow, through its own redirect URL | Repute Post, Cardiff, United Kingdom | Free listing |
| Crunchbase | Company database | Live | Yes | nofollow | Repute Post, Cardiff, United Kingdom | Free profile |
| Trustpilot | Review site | Live | Yes | nofollow (all links) | Reputepost, United States | Free; paid plans from $319 a month |
| Indie Hackers | Startup community | Live | Yes | nofollow | Reputepost (no location) | Free account |
| WebCatalog | App directory | Live | Yes | nofollow | Repute Post (no location) | Nothing: the site made the page |
| DevHunt | Launch platform | Live | Yes | nofollow (free route) | Repute Post (no location) | Free (nofollow) or $19 (followed) |
| SmartCustomer (was Sitejabber) | Review site | Live | No (robots noindex) | nofollow, through a 302 | Reputepost (no location) | Free business account |
| Techjockey | Software marketplace | Preview only | Preview page only | No link | Repute Post Inc (no location) | No listing fee |
| Clutch | Agency directory | Not public | No (410 Gone) | No profile, no link | - | Free; Verified badge $499 a year |
| AlternativeTo | Software alternatives | Not public | No (404 until approved) | None yet (in review) | Repute Post (submitted) | Free queue; $19 or $29 to jump it |
All 14 profiles checked on 20 November 2026. The name and location columns show what each profile displays, including the mistakes.
Three followed links out of 14. SaaSHub and ProvenExpert link to our home page with no rel at all. EliteAI Tools sends its links through a 302 redirect on its own domain, and that link has no rel either. Every other live profile marks its link nofollow, and SaaSHub adds nofollow to its two other links. None of the 14 profiles is among the 111 linking pages in our Ahrefs backlink export from 12 November.
Some of these directories listed us without being asked. WebCatalog and EliteAI Tools created their pages on their own; we never submitted to either. SmartCustomer (formerly Sitejabber) has an unclaimed profile set to noindex, so it does nothing in search.
Live is not the same as listed. Clutch's profile URL returns 410 Gone. AlternativeTo shows a 404 until our submission clears its free review queue. Techjockey only has a preview page, with no link. A submission gives you nothing until its public URL loads, so check that URL, not your dashboard.
One directory sells the follow. DevHunt's free queue gives a nofollow link. For $19, the same listing launches that week with a followed link. That is a paid link, and Google's spam policy treats "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam unless the link carries nofollow or sponsored. Our DevHunt page is saved but not launched, so today it shows the free nofollow link.
Each band is one profile. Left: its status on 20 November 2026. Right: the link it gives reputepost.com. Only 3 of the 14 bands end in a followed link, and one of those goes through a redirect.
Do links from directories have any value?
Some, but rarely as ranking power. Most directory links are nofollow, many profiles are thin pages that few people visit, and Google names low-quality directories in its spam policy. A good listing gives you other things: a consistent record of your business, a place for reviews and the odd visitor who is already comparing options.
Google's spam policies for web search define link spam as "the practice of creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings". Among the examples they list "Low-quality directory or bookmark site links" and "Using automated programs or services to create links to your site". A directory you join so that customers can find you is not the problem. The policy is aimed at networks of directories that exist only to hand out links.
A nofollow link isn't worthless, but it's weak. In 2019 Google said that nofollow, ugc and sponsored would be treated as hints "about which links to consider or exclude within Search". For crawling and indexing, that started on 1 March 2020. Google can still ignore a hint, so don't count a nofollow listing as a ranking link. Once you know how Google reads nofollow, ugc and sponsored, the gap between them matters less: all three are hints, and a hint from a page with no readers carries little weight.
Local businesses have a second reason to list. Google's Business Profile help says local results depend on relevance, distance and prominence. It adds that prominence is "based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have." So local citations (listings that repeat your name, address and phone number) still matter for a shop, a clinic or a trades business, even when the link itself is nofollow.
A good directory listing gives you four things:
- A citation: a third-party record of your name, location and website that matches the others.
- A brand result: profiles on large directories can rank for your company name, so the people checking you out find real reviews.
- A place for reviews: on review sites and software directories, the profile is where customers leave them.
- Referral visits: from people who are already shortlisting suppliers in your category.
What a listing won't do is replace links from pages people read. When you work out the number of links a page needs to rank, leave directory links out of the count. They make a profile look complete, not competitive.
Which SEO directories matter for which business
There's no single list of best SEO directories, because the directories that matter depend on where your customers look. Most "directories list for SEO" posts put map listings, software review sites and general web directories in one long list. Sort them by type of business and the useful part gets short.
Our working view of where to list first, by type of business. It is a starting order based on our own listings, not a rule from Google.
Local businesses: map listings and citations first
If customers visit you or you serve a local area, start with the local SEO directories behind the maps: Google Business Profile, Bing Places and Apple Business Connect. Then add the main directories in your country: in the UK, Yell, Thomson Local and FreeIndex; in the US, Yelp and the Better Business Bureau. A trade body or chamber of commerce for your sector comes next. A local business directory submission is worth doing by hand, once per site, with the same details everywhere. A local directory submission tool that sends one profile to 100 sites at once is not. For local directories, SEO value comes mostly from matching details and reviews, not from the link.
SaaS and software: review platforms buyers read
Software buyers compare tools on G2, Capterra, SaaSHub, GoodFirms and SoftwareSuggest. Launch sites such as Product Hunt and DevHunt bring a burst of early users and feedback. Two of our three followed links came from software directories (SaaSHub and EliteAI Tools); the third came from ProvenExpert, a review site. Most software directories still use nofollow, so list there for buyers and reviews first. For links that move rankings, SaaS link building on tech and marketing sites does more than another profile.
Agencies and service firms: reviewed agency directories
Agencies and consultants get found on Clutch, GoodFirms, DesignRush, Sortlist and The Manifest. The good ones review every application. GoodFirms says it accepts 23% of free applications. Clutch publishes a profile only after its team has reviewed it, and ours is not live. That filter is what makes these directories worth having. An agency that sells link building to its own clients needs more than profiles, though. That is where a white label partner fits: the links are placed for the agency and reported under its own name.
NAP consistency: the slowest fix in the log
NAP stands for your business name, address and phone number. Google's Business Profile guidelines ask you to "Represent your business as it's consistently represented and recognized in the real world across signage, stationery, and other branding." Some directories create profiles on their own (two of ours did), so a wrong detail can spread to sites you never touched.
On 3 November our profiles used four versions of the name and three locations. Trustpilot, GoodFirms and Cybo had us in the United States, ProvenExpert showed a London address with a US ZIP code, and only some profiles had Cardiff. We fixed GoodFirms, ProvenExpert and Cybo that week. By 20 November, GoodFirms, ProvenExpert, Crunchbase and SoftwareSuggest all showed Cardiff or the United Kingdom. Trustpilot still shows the United States, and four profiles still spell the name differently: Reputepost on Trustpilot, Indie Hackers and SmartCustomer, and Repute Post Inc on Techjockey.
What six profiles showed on 3 November and on 20 November 2026. Two were fixed, one was right all along, and three still show a different name or the wrong country.
Here is the order we'd follow next time. Write the details down once (name, address format, phone, website URL and a two-sentence description) and paste the same block everywhere. Fix the profiles you control first; tracking down the login for each one was our slowest step. Then claim the profiles a site made for you, and re-check them all a few weeks later, because some edits wait in a review queue before they show.
What to avoid: paid SEO directory lists and mass submission
Search for directory submission sites and you'll find lists of hundreds of "SEO directories", plus gigs that promise 200 "live dofollow" directory submissions for a few dollars. A business directory submission service of that kind sells the thing Google's policy names: links from directories that exist to give out links. At best you waste the money. At worst you end up with a link profile you have to clean up later.
Automated directory submission is worse, because one description goes to every site at once. That is close to the policy's own example of "automated programs or services to create links to your site". Old off-page SEO directory submission lists are also out of date. Many still include directories that have closed, the best known being DMOZ, which shut in March 2017.
Skip a backlink directory if any of these is true:
- It accepts every site instantly, with no review.
- Its category pages are long lists of links with no descriptions anyone would read.
- It sells a "dofollow" upgrade or a "permanent backlink".
- It has no audience of its own: no reviews, no community, nothing in search for its own name.
- It has nothing to do with your industry or your country.
Directory submission services that do it properly exist: they submit by hand to a short list and send you the live URLs. If what you really want is to stop doing link building yourself, hand the work to someone else. Pick someone who reports every link with its rel and the traffic of the page it sits on.
How to use directories to get backlinks that count
This is how to build backlinks from directories without spending a week on it, in the order we'd do it now:
- Search for your own brand first. Two of our 14 profiles existed before we asked for them. Claim those before you create duplicates.
- Pick 10 to 20 directories by business type, using the grid above: map listings and citations for local businesses, review platforms for software, reviewed agency directories for service firms.
- Write one details block and use it everywhere: name, address format, website URL and a two-sentence description. Don't add keywords to the business name.
- Submit by hand and log the public URL. A submission isn't a listing until that URL loads. Ours on Clutch and AlternativeTo don't, yet.
- Check each live profile with the console snippet above and look for noindex. A few weeks later, check which links Google has already recorded for your site.
- Stop there, and put the rest of your time into links from pages with readers. A directory profile is a base. The links that move rankings sit on pages people read: a guest post on a ReputePost site with real organic traffic (every listed site needs 1,000+ organic visitors and DR 20+), or a niche edit on a page that already ranks.
If the console feels like overkill for step 5, this 87-second video shows three free ways to check whether a link is dofollow or nofollow, and the same checks work on any directory profile.
Log updates
- 3 November 2026: first audit. We found 19 profiles, 16 of them live, using four versions of the name and three locations.
- First week of November: we fixed the HQ on GoodFirms and the address on ProvenExpert, and moved Cybo to our UK listing.
- 17 November 2026: we submitted Repute Post to AlternativeTo (free queue) and saved a DevHunt page without launching it.
- 20 November 2026: we re-checked the 14 profiles in this log. 11 are live, with 3 followed links and 8 nofollow, and Trustpilot still shows the wrong country.
- Next check: February 2027, when SaaSHub's three-monthly re-verification is due. We'll add the results here.
Related articles

Cheap Backlinks: What $10, $50 and $100 Really Buy
Ten $10 links, two $50 links or one $100 link? We sorted 15,812 approved listings by price to show what cheap backlinks really buy, the red flags in cheap offers, and how to buy safely.
19 min read

How Much Do Backlinks Cost? Prices by Link Type in 2026
Most backlinks cost $0 to about $600 in November 2026. Our 15,812 listings show traffic, not DR, sets a guest post's price. Rate card, budgets and checks.
15 min read

Relevant Backlinks: How to Find Niche Links
A DR 34 niche blog can beat a DR 71 magazine. Score any link on site topic, page topic, context and audience, see four worked examples, and find relevant backlinks that pass.
18 min read